herb butter

Slathering your steak with herb butter elevates it from merely tasty to a meal you’ll reminisce about for ages. Today, we’re gonna walk through concocting an ultimate herb butter mix that’ll elevate your Porterhouse steak from great to absolutely mind-blowing. We dive into selecting fresh herbs and incorporating unique flavors like dried ancho chili.

But it doesn’t stop there. Discover the art of cooking Porterhouse with tips on seasoning and why a cast iron skillet is your best friend in the kitchen. Plus, we share secrets on resting your steak for maximum juiciness.

After savoring your steak, let’s not forget about those mushrooms waiting to be sautéed in leftover herb butter! And because every great meal deserves a complete table setting, find out which craft beers and BBQ sides pair best with your culinary creation.

Last but not least, get inspired by global cuisines to take your herb butter from classic to extraordinary!

This post may contain affiliate links which means Pints, Forks & Friends may receive commission for purchases made through links. We only recommend products that we personally believe in and use. Learn more on our Privacy Policy page.

cowboy kent rollins cookbook

Comfort Food The Cowboy Way

French Toast Casserole
Fried Macaroni and Cheese
Red Eye Gravy and Ham
Grilled Steak and Chicken Quesadillas
Hearty Beef Stew
Smoked Queso Dip

Crafting the Perfect Herb Butter for Steak

Selecting Your Herbs

Choosing fresh herbs is like picking your squad; you want vibrant, aromatic friends that will lift you up. Go for fresh rosemary, thyme, and parsley. These fellas aren’t merely green; they’re bursting with tastes that’ll have your steak performing arias.

When it comes to herb butter, freshness is key. Those dried jars in your pantry? Leave them there. Fresh herbs bring a brightness that dried ones just can’t match. Think of it as the difference between live music and a recording – both great but undeniably different vibes.

A good rule of thumb: If it smells good to you, it’ll taste good on your steak. So don’t be shy at the market—give those leaves a little sniff test before making them part of your team.

The Role of Dried Ancho Chili

Dried ancho chili might sound like an odd player in this game but trust us; it’s the secret ingredient that takes everything from ‘good’ to ‘mind-blowingly awesome’. Introducing a bit of dried ancho chili introduces a subtle smokiness and the perfect amount of spice, elevating the dish while ensuring it remains pleasantly palatable, rather than triggering any emergency heat alerts.

Mixing ancho chili into herb butter isn’t about creating heat; it’s about adding layers of flavor—a warm backdrop against which those fresh herbs can really shine. Imagine wrapping yourself in a cozy blanket on a chilly evening—that’s what ancho does for steak.

To get started, grind or finely chop one small piece until you’ve got enough powder or flakes to mix evenly through your softened butter—usually around half teaspoon per stick should do the trick nicely without overpowering other flavors involved.

The Art of Cooking Porterhouse Steak

Imagine the Porterhouse steak as the king of meats, sitting regally on its throne—your dinner plate. In this slice, the delicate filet mignon and hearty New York strip are joined by a T-bone, enriching the taste as it cooks.

Why Choose Porterhouse?

Choosing a Porterhouse means getting two steaks in one. The larger side is juicy and flavorful, known as the New York strip, while the smaller side is buttery soft—the famed filet mignon. But size matters here; for a steak to be officially called ‘Porterhouse,’ it needs to have at least 1.25 inches of meat across its widest point. Anything less struts into T-bone territory.

This generous cut not only promises variety but also ensures there’s something on your plate for every kind of carnivore out there.

Seasoning Secrets

To elevate this noble cut, start with salt and pepper—but don’t stop there. A touch of garlic powder and rosemary can transport your taste buds straight to culinary heaven before you even take your first bite.

Salt acts like a magic wand—it draws moisture from within the steak to its surface where it mixes with those herbs and spices creating an unforgettable crust when seared in cast iron skillet bliss.

Cast Iron Skillet Magic

If you’ve ever wondered why your steak doesn’t taste quite like the one from your favorite restaurant, the secret might just be sitting in your kitchen already: a cast iron skillet. Far from being merely decorative, this vintage culinary gear plays a pivotal role in crafting the quintessential char on your cherished Porterhouse.

But before you start, make sure to give that skillet some love. A well-seasoned cast iron isn’t something to overlook—it’s what makes or breaks the magic. Seasoning creates a non-stick surface and adds depth of flavor that gets better with every use. Think of it as a good wine; it only improves with age.

Caring for this heavy-duty pan is simpler than decoding grandma’s secret recipes. After cooking, let it cool down then wash gently with water—soap if you must but sparingly so—and dry thoroughly because rust is the enemy here folks. Then rub it all over with oil and heat it up again until smoking slightly to re-season. Voila. Ready for next time.

Maintaining your cast iron means endless possibilities beyond steaks too—from crispy-skinned fish to golden-brown cornbread, making this versatile pan worth its weight in gold in any kitchen arsenal.

Resting Your Steak

So, you’ve seared your steak to that perfect golden crust, and the aroma is making your stomach sing. But before you slice into that beautiful piece of Porterhouse, let’s talk about why giving it a rest is as crucial as the cook itself.

Think of resting your steak as letting it catch its breath after a sprint. When heated, the juices in the steak move towards the surface and if cut too soon, those flavorful juices end up on your plate instead of in each bite. Resting allows these juices to redistribute throughout the meat, ensuring every slice is succulent and full of flavor.

The rule of thumb here? Let your steak rest for about half its cooking time. This might test your patience but think about how all good things come to those who wait. And while waiting might seem like doing nothing, what’s happening inside that sizzling beauty is essential for locking in moisture and flavor. So next time you’re tempted to skip this step, remember, patience isn’t just a virtue; it’s the secret ingredient for a mouthwatering steak.

Bonus Round: Mushrooms in Herb Butter

After enjoying your steak, that flavorful herb butter shouldn’t just sit there looking pretty. It’s got a second act with mushrooms that’ll knock your socks off. Think of it as the encore at a rock concert but for your taste buds.

Mushrooms have this magical way of soaking up flavors like a sponge in water. When they meet herb butter, it’s like they’ve found their soulmate. The key here is to get them golden and crispy on the outside while tender on the inside. A medium heat works wonders, letting those herbs sing without turning bitter.

Now, don’t just throw any old mushroom into the pan and call it a day. Opt for varieties like cremini or shiitake that stand up well to sautéing. They bring their own earthy notes to the party which complements the aromatic herbs beautifully. Bon Appétit has an excellent guide on choosing mushrooms if you’re scratching your head at this point.

To wrap things up (but not literally), finishing these bad boys with a splash of white wine can elevate them from great to unforgettable by adding acidity and depth – because why should steak have all the fun?

Pairing Your Steak with Craft Beer and BBQ Sides

Selecting the Perfect Craft Beer

When your Porterhouse steak is sizzling, you’ll want a craft beer that stands up to its rich flavors. Think of a stout or porter, like Founders KBS or Deschutes Black Butte Porter. These beers have the body and complexity to complement the buttery herbaceousness of your steak without overpowering it.

Avoid lighter beers here; they might get lost in translation between bites. It’s like bringing a knife to a gunfight – not quite enough firepower.

Choosing Your BBQ Sides

No steak dinner is complete without sides that can hold their own. For something green, grilled asparagus spears drizzled with olive oil and sea salt offer a smoky crunch that dances well with both the beer and steak.

Mashing sweet potatoes with a hint of cinnamon and nutmeg provides a grounded counterpoint, offsetting the feast’s opulence and injecting lively hues onto your dish.

Crafting these combinations transcends mere flavor; it’s about weaving together moments where each gulp and morsel complement one another in perfect harmony. So go ahead, give it a try. You’ll find these combinations bring out nuances in flavor you might not have noticed before.

Travel Inspired Herb Butter Variations

Who said butter couldn’t be an international affair? Spice up your Porterhouse steak with herb butters inspired by global cuisines. It’s like sending your taste buds on a world tour, no passport required.

Selecting Your Herbs

Fresh herbs are the soul of any good herb butter. But don’t just stick to what you know; explore. Think Italian with basil and oregano or maybe French with tarragon and chervil. Each choice brings its own unique flair to the table.

Dive into this handbook for picking the freshest herbs to ensure your dishes burst with unmatched flavor. It’ll help make sure those flavors pop exactly how they should.

The Role of Dried Ancho Chili

Now for a twist – dried ancho chili. Diving into this, the magic isn’t solely in the spice but in how it intricately enhances the steak’s robustness with a complexity of taste that’s almost mystical until experienced firsthand.

Incorporating anchos infuses a mundane herb butter with an unexpected sweet and smoky twist, elevating it to unparalleled levels of flavor. For more insight into using these versatile chilies, take a peek at some tips from experts in Mexican cuisine here.

Herb Butter Recipe – Cowboy Kent Rollins

Prep Time: 3 Hours  // Total Time: 3 Hours 15 Minutes
Serves 2


  • 1 Porterhouse steak (28 ounces)
  • Lime juice for rubbing
  • Your preferred seasoning blend or Red River Ranch Original Seasoning
  • 2 tablespoons of coarse ground black pepper
  • 1 stick plus 1 tablespoon of unsalted butter, softened (divided)
  • 2 cloves of garlic, minced
  • 1 sprig of fresh rosemary, finely chopped
  • 1 tablespoon of fresh thyme, finely chopped
  • 1 tablespoon of green onion, finely chopped
  • ½ tablespoon of dried ancho chili, finely crushed
  • 2 tablespoons of avocado oil
  • 1 lb. of sliced mushrooms (optional)


  1. Begin by massaging both sides of the steak with lime juice and your chosen seasoning blend. Press the coarse ground pepper onto the steak’s outer edges, then refrigerate it for 1 hour.
  2. Allow the steak to reach room temperature, approximately 2 hours, to ensure it cooks evenly.
  3. While the steak is warming up, prepare the herb butter. Combine a stick of softened butter in a bowl with minced garlic, diced rosemary, thyme, green onion, and crushed ancho chili. Mix well.
  4. Place the mixed butter onto plastic wrap, shaping it into a log. Wrap it up and refrigerate for 1 hour.
  5. Heat a skillet over medium-high with the remaining butter and avocado oil. Once hot, place the steak in the skillet, cooking for 4 minutes on each side.
  6. Add 2 tablespoons of the prepared herb butter into the skillet and another tablespoon directly on the steak, basting the steak with the melting butter for 2 minutes. Repeat the process after flipping the steak, ensuring constant basting.
  7. After cooking, let the steak rest for 5 minutes.
  8. Lower the heat to medium, and in the same skillet, add mushrooms to the remaining butter, cooking until tender, about 4 minutes. Add more herb butter if desired.
  9. Serve the steak hot, garnished with the sautéed mushrooms.

FAQs in Relation to Herb Butter

What is the meaning of herb butter?

Herb butter mixes softened butter with fresh or dried herbs, boosting flavor in meats, veggies, and bread.

How long is herb butter good for?

In the fridge, herb butter stays fresh for about two weeks. In the freezer, it lasts up to six months.

What is cowboy butter made of?

Cowboy butter blends garlic, lemon juice, dijon mustard, Worcestershire sauce, spices and herbs into rich creamy goodness.

What is garlic herb butter made of?

This tasty mix combines minced garlic with finely chopped herbs like parsley and chives into smooth unsalted or salted butter.


Crafting herb butter transcends mere culinary activity; it embarks you on a journey through the rich landscapes of taste. Mastering the art of herb butter, you’ve transitioned from merely selecting fresh greens to expertly fusing them with complex seasonings such as desiccated ancho chili.

Steak night changed forever because you now know how a Porterhouse can shine brighter with the right seasoning and a cast iron skillet’s magic touch.

Remember: letting your steak rest is not optional but essential for that burst of juiciness. And those mushrooms in herb butter? A revelation on their own.

Pairing your masterpiece with craft beer and BBQ sides only elevates the experience. Diving into the vast flavors of global dishes can spark creativity for your upcoming herb butter concoction, if you’re up for a culinary exploration.

In this journey, one thing remains clear: Herb butter transforms good into unforgettable. Start simple, experiment boldly, and enjoy every bite along the way.

If you read this far, you dig us!! You will really dig this article: The Original Cowboy Butter

Pints Forks Friends Amazon Shop

Find us on Amazon! Pints, Forks & Friends Shop

Our Amazon Shop

Pints, Forks & Friends stands as your premier spot for savoring the quintessential American indulgence. In our Amazon shop, we meticulously handpick products that cater to the heart of backyard BBQs, the joy of sipping refreshing beverages, and the necessity of practical everyday items. Whether you’re looking to elevate your outdoor cooking experience, enjoy a chilled drink on a sunny day, or find those must-have daily essentials, our curated selection is designed to enhance every aspect of your culinary and leisure pursuits.

The Latest…


Pin It on Pinterest

Share This