cowboy butter for steaks

Listen up, butter lovers. I’ve got a secret weapon that’ll make your taste buds sing and your steaks sizzle. It’s called cowboy butter, and it’s about to change your culinary game forever.

This magical mix of butter, garlic, herbs, and spices is like a flavor bomb for your favorite dishes. Slap it on a juicy steak fresh off the grill, and you’ll be in carnivore heaven. But don’t stop there – this versatile butter is ready to rock your world beyond the grill.

I’m talking veggies, breads, you name it. Cowboy butter is here to elevate your cooking from “meh” to “oh my god, I can’t stop eating this.” So, grab your apron and let’s get down to business. It’s time to unleash your inner cowboy (or cowgirl) and master the art of crafting this flavor-packed butter.

Need more recipes? Check out the Blackstone Griddling: The Ultimate Guide to Show-Stopping Recipes on Your Outdoor Gas Griddle or our new “Griddled Cheese” Adventures!

This post may contain affiliate links which means Pints, Forks & Friends may receive commission for purchases made through links. We only recommend products that we personally believe in and use. Learn more on our Privacy Policy page.

blackstone griddle accessories

#1 Best Seller in Barbecue Tool Sets! 18 piece Griddle Accessory Kit
*Check Out the Best Sellers at Blackstone Griddles

Make the Perfect Cowboy Butter

Let’s talk about a game-changer in the world of compound butters: cowboy butter. This flavor-packed spread is about to revolutionize your steak nights and elevate your culinary creations to new heights. Cowboy butter is a blend of butter, herbs, spices, and a kick of heat that’ll make your taste buds sing. It’s the perfect topping for grilled meats, veggies, and even bread. Trust me, once you’ve tried it, you’ll be hooked.

Selecting Your Butter Base

The foundation of any great cowboy butter is, well, the butter. And when it comes to choosing between salted and unsalted butter, it’s all about balance. Unsalted butter lets you control the salt content and really let the other flavors shine. But if you opt for salted butter, just keep in mind that you might want to dial back the added salt in the recipe. Personally, I like using high-quality, grass-fed unsalted butter. It’s got a richer flavor and a creamier texture that really takes this compound butter to the next level.

cowboy butter blackstone

Flavor Profile Building Blocks

Now, let’s talk about the stars of the show: the ingredients that give cowboy butter its signature kick. We’re talking garlic, shallot, thyme, chives, parsley, lemon zest and juice, ancho chili, smoked paprika, crushed red pepper, prepared horseradish, and Dijon mustard. Each component plays a crucial role in creating a complex, well-rounded flavor profile. The garlic and shallot bring a savory depth, while the fresh herbs add a bright, aromatic note. Lemon zest and juice provide a tangy freshness that cuts through the richness of the butter. But the real magic happens with the spices. Ancho chili and smoked paprika give the butter a warm, smoky flavor, while the crushed red pepper and horseradish add a subtle heat that keeps you coming back for more. And let’s not forget the Dijon mustard, which ties everything together with its sharp, tangy bite.

Gentle Cooking for Flavor Fusion

The key to a truly exceptional cowboy butter is in the cooking process. You want to gently melt the butter and cook the ingredients just enough to release their flavors and allow them to meld together. Keep the heat low and stir frequently to prevent the garlic and shallots from burning. You’re looking for a gentle simmer, not a rolling boil. This low and slow approach ensures that all the flavors have a chance to get to know each other and create a harmonious blend. Once everything is melted and combined, remove the pan from the heat and let the mixture cool slightly. This resting period is crucial for allowing the flavors to deepen and intensify. Trust me, the aroma wafting from your kitchen will have everyone’s mouths watering. And the best part? You’re just getting started.

Serving Suggestions for Cowboy Butter

Now that you’ve crafted the perfect batch of cowboy butter, it’s time to put it to work. And let me tell you, the possibilities are endless.

Elevating Grilled Steak

First and foremost, cowboy butter is a steak’s best friend. There’s just something about the way the rich, smoky flavors of the butter melt into a perfectly grilled steak that takes it from ordinary to extraordinary. For an extra indulgent treat, try it on a filet mignon. This pricey cut of beef is known for its tender texture and mild flavor, which makes it the perfect canvas for cowboy butter’s bold personality. To really make your steak sing, I recommend a two-stage seasoning process. Start with a simple salt and pepper rub to create a savory base. Then, just before serving, top your steak with a generous dollop of cowboy butter and let it melt into a glorious, flavor-packed puddle. The combination of the salty, peppery crust and the rich, herb-infused butter is nothing short of magical. It’s a steakhouse-worthy experience right in your own backyard.

Beyond Steak – Versatile Pairings

But cowboy butter isn’t just for steak. Oh no, my friend. This versatile compound butter is ready to take your entire menu to the next level. Try it on grilled chicken, pork chops, or even fish. The lemon and herb notes pair particularly well with seafood, while the smoky heat complements heartier meats. And don’t forget about your veggies. Brush some cowboy butter on grilled corn on the cob, asparagus, or zucchini for a flavor-packed side dish that’ll steal the show. But my personal favorite way to enjoy cowboy butter? Slathered on a crusty piece of bread. It’s like garlic bread’s cooler, more adventurous cousin. Perfect for sopping up any stray juices on your plate or just savoring on its own. The beauty of cowboy butter is that it’s incredibly versatile. It’s ready to jazz up any dish that could use a little extra oomph. So don’t be afraid to get creative and experiment with different pairings. Your taste buds will thank you.

Preserving Cowboy Butter for Future Use

Now, I know what you’re thinking. You’ve whipped up a batch of cowboy butter, and it’s so delicious that you want to put it on everything. But what about leftovers? Can you save this magical concoction for later? The answer is a resounding yes. In fact, cowboy butter is the gift that keeps on giving. With a few simple storage techniques, you can enjoy its flavor-packed goodness for weeks to come.

Freezing Cowboy Butter Correctly

One of the best ways to preserve cowboy butter is by freezing it. Not only does this extend its shelf life, but it also allows you to portion it out for easy use later on. To freeze your cowboy butter, start by spooning it onto a sheet of parchment paper or wax paper. Use a spoon or butter knife to create small mounds, each about the size of a tablespoon. Next, fold the paper over the butter mounds and carefully roll it up, creating a log shape. Twist the ends of the paper to seal it, and then place the log in a freezer-safe container or zip-top bag. When you’re ready to use your cowboy butter, simply slice off a portion and let it thaw in the refrigerator or at room temperature. This method allows you to use just what you need without having to thaw the entire batch. Freezing your cowboy butter in smaller portions also helps maintain its flavor and texture. Just like resting your steak before slicing allows the juices to redistribute, letting your cowboy butter set properly ensures that the flavors are evenly distributed and the texture is just right.

Shelf Life and Storage Tips

So, how long can you keep cowboy butter on hand? When stored properly in the refrigerator, cowboy butter will last for up to two weeks. But if you opt for the freezer method, you can extend its shelf life to several months. To maximize freshness, make sure to store your cowboy butter in an airtight container. This will prevent it from absorbing any funky fridge odors and keep it tasting its best. If you’ve frozen your cowboy butter, be sure to transfer it to the refrigerator a day before you plan to use it. This will give it time to thaw slowly and evenly, ensuring that the texture remains smooth and spreadable. And if you find yourself with a surplus of fresh herbs or other ingredients, consider making a double or triple batch of cowboy butter. It’s a great way to use up any extras and ensure that you always have this flavor-boosting spread on hand. With these simple storage tips, you can enjoy the bold, smoky flavors of cowboy butter anytime the craving strikes. Whether you’re grilling up a steak, jazzing up some veggies, or just spreading it on a piece of toast, this compound butter is sure to become a staple in your kitchen.

Key Takeaway: 
Cowboy butter, a flavor-packed compound butter with herbs, spices, and a hint of heat, transforms steaks and dishes into culinary delights. Use unsalted butter for control over saltiness and savor the blend of garlic, shallot, lemon zest & juice, ancho chili among others for its signature kick. Cook gently to meld flavors then enjoy on meats or veggies.


Cowboy butter is more than just a condiment – it’s a game-changer. With its bold flavors and versatility, it transforms ordinary dishes into gourmet delights. From elevating steaks to adding zing to veggies, this compound butter is your secret weapon in the kitchen.

But the best part? You can make a big batch and store it for later, so you always have cowboy butter ready to rock when the craving strikes. Freeze it, slice it, and savor the flavor explosion whenever your heart desires.

So, whether you’re a grill master, a veggie lover, or just a fan of damn good food, give cowboy butter a try. Your taste buds will thank you, and your guests will be begging for your secret recipe. Saddle up, butter enthusiasts – it’s time to embrace your inner cowboy and ride off into the sunset of flavor.

Pints Forks Friends Amazon Shop

Find us on Amazon! Pints, Forks & Friends Shop

The Latest…


Pin It on Pinterest

Share This

Share This

Share this post with your friends!