I Can Do Another 12
Chicken Wing Review – I Can Do Another 12 History
We always had this idea and love for chicken wings. After the Covid-19 pandemic, we decided to lend our support to local bars and restaurants by launching an engaging chicken wing review show called “I Can Do Another 12.”
What is the I Can Do Another 12 History? The simplest explanation is that we were all eating and drinking at an oyster bar when the waitress asked if we wanted anything else. PFFMaestro replied, “Yeah, I Can Do Another 12,” which provoked a lot of laughter at the table.
In the beginning, we would just do a photo social media post, tagging the place, and that was pretty much it. We felt the need to expand and turn it into an actual video show. We’re mapping all the episodes as seasons that run from January to December yearly. We’ve crossed the 30-episode milestone and began Season 2 in January 2023. It’s been an enriching journey, meeting a diverse array of people, surpassing all my initial expectations. The main aim is to spotlight the best chicken wings around while offering complimentary publicity for these remarkable local businesses. Cheers!
Below is our original charting and scoring…
How it Began – I Can Do Another 12 History
| LOCATION | SCORE | NOTES |
|---|---|---|
| Red Onion - Monroe, OH | 9.8 | Best marinated & smoked & grilled wings, too bad this placed is closed, but it's a classic |
| Fat Head's Brewery - Canton | 9.7 | Outstanding smoked whole wings with their OG sauce - A must try! |
| Papa Joe's - Akron, OH | 9.7 | smoked & grilled wings with exceptional flavor - crispy confit |
| Ray's in Fairlawn | 9.6 | slow smoked hickory wings - hot sauce was the move, but other sauces are delicious too |
| The Merchant Tavern | 9.5 | Jumbo wings brined and tossed in sriracha cockfight sauce - a must try! |
| Basement Bar & Grill - Akron, OH | 9.0 | Great Bar wings - buffalo sauce was great. Bar wings usually don't make into 9's either. |
| Cooter's Restaurant - Clearwater, FL | 9 | tequila daytona style with a little grill char |
| Little Wing Cafe - Warren, OH | 8.9 | Classic hot wings - Madd Hatters flavor was sneaky hot |
| Firehouse Tavern - Copley, OH | 8.9 | Creative sauces - Salt & Vinegar, Backdraft - sweet with a heater back end |
| Melt Bar & Grilled - Akron, OH | 8.8 | ordered their delicious "awesome sauce" wings -with a side of mac&cheese for the win |
| M&M's Taphouse - Barberton, OH | 8.8 | classic bar chicken wings with special sauce! |
| Fisher's Cafe & Pub - Peninsula, OH | 8.8 | tasty & fiery hot wings! really enjoyed this place |
| Tailgaters - Wadsworth, OH | 8.8 | Mango habanero, cajun, kickinbourbon, lemonpepperwings - very good |
| Galaxy - Wadsworth, OH | 8.8 | hot garlic or mango habanero very tasty, with good crisp |
| Duffy's - Cape Coral | 8.7 | huge wings, bbq sauce was delicious |
| Gasoline Alley - Akron, OH | 8.6 | solid bar style buffalo hot wings |
| Winking Lizard - Akron, OH | 8.5 | classic chicken wings - good bufffalo style flavor |
| Frank's Place - Akron | 8.4 | Solid bar wings - garlic parm, hot bbq, Frank's Red Hot, and cajun are all tasty choices - Sunday wing special is perfect! |
| Craft Social Bar - Cuyahoga Falls, OH | 8.4 | solid bar style buffalo hot wings - over sauced |
| Canal Boat Lounge - Canal Fulton, OH | 8.3 | great dive bar wings, a lot of flavor |
| Pick's at PLX - Portage Lakes | 8.1 | Good bar style hot wings - flavor was there |
| Town Tavern, Montrose OH | 7.8 | Very tasty wings and great local atmosphere |
| Tres Potrillos - Copley, Oh | 7.7 | solid buffalo wings at a mexican restaurant no doubt! |
| Retz's Laconi's - Cuyahoga Falls | 6.8 | very saucy, solid bar wings |
| Domino's - Wadsworth, OH | 5.5 | wings were mushy/processed - mango habanero sauce saved the disaster |
Future Reviews…
This list is very fluid as we keep receiving tips of places with great chicken wings.
| FUTURE REVEIW LIST | ||
|---|---|---|
| Wing Warehouse | ||
| Marie's Pizza | ||
| Kip's Pizza | ||
| Whitey's | ||
| Jerzees | ||
| Dechechos Pizza | ||
| Woody's Bar | ||
| Pizza Bella - Kenmore | ||
| Manchester Tavern | ||
| Putty's Kitchen - Merriman Valley | ||
| Windsor Pub | ||
| Your Pizza Shop | ||
| Tim's Pizzaria | ||
| DeChecoโs | ||
| Sammie's - Tallmadge | ||
| Lock 15 | ||
| Bistro on Main - Kent | ||
| Panini's - Kent | ||
| Mr G's | ||
| Beau's | ||
| Missing Falls Brewery | ||
| Main Street Grill | ||
| Firehouse - Tallmadge | ||
| Clubhouse - Cuyahoga Falls | ||
| Fire and Ice - Triplett Blvd | ||
| Regina's Pizza - Kenmore | ||
| Showcase Meats | ||
| Main Street Saloon | ||
| Roosters | ||
| Brew Kettle | ||
| Wolf Creek Tavern | ||
| Eldorados | ||
| On Tap's | ||
| Beef o Brady's | ||
| Bubba's 33 | ||
| Redstone Pub | ||
| New Mitford Cafe | ||
| The Brew House | ||
| Hooley House | ||
| Barmacy! | ||
| Tommyโs Bar and Grille | ||
| Barley House | ||
| Johnny's Pub and Grille | ||
| Rusty Railz - Clinton | ||
| Quaker Steak & Lube | ||
| TD's - Canton | ||
| Village Gardens |
1-10 GRADING SCALE
Expected Ranges
- 1-5 = Bad wings
- 6-7 = Average wings
- 8 = Very good wings, bar styled
- 9 = Exceptional wings, grilled, smoked etc.
- 10 = No such thing.
I Can Do Another 12 History – The Latest Episodes
Brew-Wing Lab, EPCOT โ I Can Do Another 12, Episode 036
When PFFMaestro, PFFNinja, and our special guest reviewer,...
Winking Lizard Macedonia โ I Can Do Another 12, Episode 035
Winking Lizard Macedonia โ "I Can Do Another 12," Episode...
Noisy Oyster Pub โ I Can Do Another 12, Episode 034
In this episode of "I Can Do Another 12", @PFFMaestro and...
Sometimes the โranch enhancerโ is the move wit those bar-style wings๐ค๐ Episode #021 Timโs Pizzeria & Pub #ICanDoAnother12 is up on our YouTube channel! #supportlocal and stop by!!
โ
#pintsforksfriends #hotwings #chickenwings #bbqwings #pub #timspizzeria #cuyahogafalls #eatlocal #drinklocal #wingstop
๐จ #icandoanother12 review!๐ After paddling 6 miles on the river one of our favorite joints is the Canal Boat Lounge. They donโt really promote them, but their #hotwings are LEGIT! We enjoyed up on their upstairs deck over a bucket of beers. We scored it a boomin 8.3 ๐ฅ๐ปPlease check this sleepy spot out! #pfflife
โ
#pintsforksfriends #eatlocal #drinklocal #chickenwings #bbqwings #garlicparmesanwings #yardbirds #meatchickens #canalfulton #meetupspot #eatoutside #canalboatlounge #wingwednesday
๐จ #icandoanother12 review! We had some of the biggest #chickenwings ever over at @duffysmvp They were ReDONKS - recommend the @jackdaniels_us #bbqsauce ๐ we scored it an amazing 8.7 ๐ป๐ฅ #pfflife
โ
#pintsforksfriends #eatlocal #drinklocal #hotwings #wings #instagood #yardbird #duffysdrinkselfie #bbqwings #duffys #capecoral
๐จ #icandoanother12 review!๐ฅ๐ We stopped by #fisherscafeandpub in beautiful Peninsula Ohio. Theyโre family owned and celebrating 63 years in business. Outstanding atmosphere, we sat on the patio next to the bar. Wings were delicious with their โFisherโs Firecracker Blendโ - Official score: 8.8๐๐ป We paired it with @rsheabrewing Towpath #lager which was ReDONKS. PLEASE STOP BY and check them out. Oh their Canal #chili is phenomenal as well ๐ป๐ #pfflife
โ
#pintsforksfriends #eatlocal #drinklocal #happyhour #meetupspot #rsheabrewing #hopheads #chickenwings #wingsandbeer #instagood #hotwings๐ฅ
๐จ #icandoanother12 review! ๐ฅ๐๐ป We hit up @beefobradys1985 for their #wingwednesday special slamming some #nashvillehot and buffalo #hotwings sauces. Final score was a solid 8.1๐ They have a full bar & nice atmosphere. Please check them out! #pfflife
โ
#pintsforksfriends #eatlocal #drinklocal #happyhour #chickenwings #wingsofinstagram #meetupspot #meatchickens #yardbird
๐จ #icandoanother12 review!๐ฅ๐ We hit up the new @firehousetaverncopley which is what Copley needed. The wings were very very tasty. Sauces were very creative... Salt & vinegar and Backdraft is what we got. We scored it an 8.9 -which is the highest score we give in the bar/fried style. PLEASE SUPPORT THIS NEW SPOT!!๐ป๐ #pfflife #pffstamp
โ
#pintsforksfriends #eatlocal #drinklocal #wings #chickenwings #wingstop #hotwings #wingsofinstagram #beerandwings #happyhour #meetupspot
๐จ #icandoanother12 review!๐ฅ๐ We hit up the new firehousetaverncopley which is what Copley needed. The wings were very very tasty. Sauces were very creative... Salt & vinegar and Backdraft is what we got. We scored it an 8.9 -which is the highest score we give in the bar/fried style. PLEASE SUPPORT THIS NEW SPOT!!๐ป๐ #pfflife #pffstamp
โ
#pintsforksfriends #eatlocal #drinklocal #wings #chickenwings #wingstop #hotwings #wingsofinstagram #beerandwings #happyhour #meetupspot
๐จ#icandoanother12 review!! We had a #hotwings extravaganza over at @tailgatorsgrill -We tried #mangohabanero #cajun #kickinbourbon #lemonpepperwings All were ReDONKS... Overall score was 8.8 ๐ฅ๐ -paired with @rhinegeist #truthipa ๐ปNext time youโre in Wadsworth give them a try #wingwednesday #pfflife
โ
#pintsforksfriends #eatlocal #drinklocal #shoplocal #hopheads #chickenwings #wingsandbeer
๐จ#icandoanother12 review! Back in February we hit @beach_fire twice and their #hotwings๐ฅ๐were legit. This is a classic bar down in #clearwaterbeach ~ We scored it 7.9 and will hit that place up again next time!! #pfflife
โ
#pintsforksfriends #chickenwings #eatlocal #supportlocal #drinklocal #meetupspot #wingstop #chickensofinstagram #craftbeerlife #wingsandbeer #bar
๐จ#icandoanother12 review!๐ฅ๐ over at the @craft_social_bar -They had some tasty little yardbirds for sure, prepare to get saucey because ours were slathered up. We scored it at a solid 8.4. Love the atmosphere and I heard they have a secret back room for private party functions. If youโre down on Front Street please stop in. Cheers! #pfflife ๐ป๐
-little history, this place was our home base when we did an Arloโs Craft Beer Tour back in the day. Owners & staff are great.
โ
#pintsforksfriends #eatlocal #drinklocal #hotwings #chickenwings #wingstop #meetupspot #cuyahogafalls
๐จ #icandoanother12 review... Revisiting @gasoline_alley wings, this time going with the #hotgarlicsauce which increase their score to a majestic 8.6๐ฅ๐๐ป Paired those dozen with a @rhinegeist #truthipa LFG!! #pfflife
โ
#pintsforksfriends #chickenwings #hotwings #wingstop #bbqlife #eatlocal #drinklocal #wingsandbeer #wingsandpizza #meetupspot
๐จ#icandoanother12 review coming in hot! Wanted to give @galaxyrestaurantoh a shout out for some delicious wings. In fact, this increases their score to an 8.8. They were our first review on our quest of the baller #chickenwings - We recommend the mango habanero or hot garlic parmesan sauces. Paired it with a @heavyseasbeer #tropicannonipa ๐ป๐ฅ๐
โ
#pintsforksfriends #wingstop #hotwings #meetupspot #eatlocal #drinklocal #pfflife #barstools
๐จ #icandoanother12 review... The family was getting a @dominos pizza so we added a #hotwings order to see how theyโre doing. Realizing these are fast food #chickenwings I went with the Sweet Mango Habanero Sauce and itโs what saved it. Wings were mushy, maybe next time Iโll finish them off on my grill ๐. Overall 5.5... Sauce was tasty!๐๐ฅ๐ป
โ
#pintsforksfriends #wingstop #wingsofinstagram #dominos๐ #chickenwings #pfflife #craftbeerlife
yO! ๐จ #icandoanother12 review... We had bodacious ๐ฅ#hotgarlicwings at @lizardvillebeerstore in Montrose earning - 8.5. Simply delicious paired with a #riegele #pilsner ๐ปWe will be back for sure living that #pfflife
โ
#pintsforksfriends #eatocal #drinklocal #meetupspot #craftbeerlife #chickenwings #hotwings #wingstop #wingslovers
๐จ๐จ๐จ #icandoanother12 review!! We absolutely went to work on some outstanding #hotwings๐ฅ over at The Little Wing Cafe while passing through #warrenohio ~ we had the Madd Hatters sneaky hot flava. We scored it an exceptional 8.9. We found them via @googlemaps Cheers to all the #winglovers and the local joints cooking them up! -paired with a @yuenglingbeer ๐ป๐๐
โ
#pintsforksfriends #eatlocal #drinklocal #chickenwings #meetupspot #littlewingcafe #lagerlife #wingstop #wingsandbeer #pfflife
One of the coolest spots around and their buffalo wings are amazing... Earning them an #icandoanother12 score of 8.4๐ฅ๐๐๐ป Thanks @gasoline_alley weโll be back for more! - Paired with a @rhinegeist #truthipa #pintsforksfriends
โ
#eatlocal #drinklocal #meetupspot #hotwings๐ฅ #bbqwings #chickenwings #pfflife
We are on a roll... Another #icandoanother12 wing review. We visited @meltbargrilled in Montrose and had some tasty #buffalohotwings - ๐ฅ๐ First the sauce was delicious and these probably would hit the 9`s if the kitchen/service was quicker. Although there were some high maintenance customer tables around us ๐ Anyways enjoyed the wings with a @rhinegeist #truthipa ๐ป๐ป We will be back for another 12! #pintsforksfriends
--
#eatlocal #drinklocal #wingstop #chickenwings #meetupspot #craftbeerlife